| 6 | AE Johns | Oxford University v Australians | 1896 | f4438 |
| 6 | GF Wheldon | Oxford University v Worcestershire | 1905 | f6586 |
| 6 | WAS Oldfield | Oxford University v Australians | 1934 | f14550 |
| 5 | TW Oates | Oxford University v Marylebone Cricket Club | 1901 | f5533 |
| 5 | FH Huish | Oxford University v Kent | 1905 | f6591 |
| 5 | GRA Langley | Oxford University v Australians | 1953 | f19979 |
Created by the CricketArchive Oracles