| 5 | FCM Alexander | England v West Indies | 1959/60 | t485 |
| 5 | PJL Dujon | England v West Indies | 1985/86 | t1042 |
| 5 | RC Russell | West Indies v England | 1989/90 | t1143 |
| 5 | Moin Khan | West Indies v Pakistan | 1992/93 | t1221 |
| 5 | Kamran Akmal | West Indies v Pakistan | 2004/05 | t1752 |
| 4 | FCM Alexander | Pakistan v West Indies | 1957/58 | t446 |
| 4 | DM Lewis | India v West Indies | 1970/71 | t685 |
| 4 | KJ Wadsworth | West Indies v New Zealand | 1971/72 | t695 |
| 4 | DL Murray | England v West Indies | 1973/74 | t734 |
| 4 | DL Bairstow | West Indies v England | 1980/81 | t900 |
| 4 | PJL Dujon | Australia v West Indies | 1983/84 | t986 |
| 4 | PJL Dujon | India v West Indies | 1988/89 | t1118 |
| 4 | DJ Richardson | West Indies v South Africa | 1991/92 | t1188 |
| 4 | JR Murray | England v West Indies | 1993/94 | t1258 |
| 4 | CO Browne | New Zealand v West Indies | 1995/96 | t1325 |
| 4 | CO Browne | India v West Indies | 1996/97 | t1363 |
| 4 | MV Boucher | West Indies v South Africa | 2004/05 | t1749 |
| 4 | BJ Haddin | West Indies v Australia | 2008 | t1879 |
Created by the CricketArchive Oracles