| 5 | RS Grant | England v West Indies | 1934/35 | t238 |
| 5 | BC Lara | South Africa v West Indies | 1991/92 | t1188 |
| 5 | KOA Powell | Zimbabwe v West Indies | 2012/13 | t2079 |
| 4 | LN Constantine | England v West Indies | 1929/30 | t187 |
| 4 | GAE Paine | West Indies v England | 1934/35 | t238 |
| 4 | JT Ikin | West Indies v England | 1947/48 | t293 |
| 4 | FMM Worrell | India v West Indies | 1952/53 | t366 |
| 4 | W Mathias | West Indies v Pakistan | 1957/58 | t446 |
| 4 | FMM Worrell | India v West Indies | 1961/62 | t527 |
| 4 | RB Simpson | West Indies v Australia | 1964/65 | t589 |
| 4 | J Garner | Pakistan v West Indies | 1976/77 | t797 |
| 4 | JJ Crowe | West Indies v New Zealand | 1984/85 | t1015 |
| 4 | CG Greenidge | Pakistan v West Indies | 1987/88 | t1097 |
| 4 | ME Waugh | West Indies v Australia | 1990/91 | t1169 |
| 4 | GP Thorpe | West Indies v England | 1993/94 | t1258 |
| 4 | SR Waugh | West Indies v Australia | 1994/95 | t1294 |
| 4 | MA Taylor | West Indies v Australia | 1994/95 | t1294 |
| 4 | JC Adams | Pakistan v West Indies | 1999/00 | t1496 |
| 4 | BC Lara | New Zealand v West Indies | 2002 | t1607 |
Created by the CricketArchive Oracles